Skip to content 
Introduction
Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting is created by the union of two great tastes added to toothsome sweetness β the tangy flavor of cream cheese and the earthy-sweet flavor of peanut butter. This frosting is best suited to be used on cakes, or cupcakes or can be placed on a dish as a dip. Here you will find the simple recipe, other possibilities, and the story of how I started to enjoy this frosting.
Why Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting?
Try to think of a frosting that does not include too much sugar mixed nicely with the main ingredients. The Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting well captures that compatibility. A marriage of sour cream cheese and the silky smooth peanut butter makes it so tasty.
A Baking Journey
One day I was in search of a very unique birthday gift for my son. He likes peanut butter so I tried to make a cake that he would never fail to notice on the dining table. Then I came across the concept of what is known as the Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting. The first time he tasted it, he smiled, this was the look of pure happiness I had not seen in a long time!
This frosting has since then become a reality in our frequent household usage. Not a party is complete without it; itβs not just for kidsβ birthday parties anymore but for family dinners or holiday meals. The best part is that it is one of the simplest recipes that anyone could ever prepare, and it is delicious.
Ingredients Youβll Need
1- Cream cheese: It offers a tasty fresh base as well as an acidity finish.
2- Peanut butter: This is beneficial in providing extra richness and gives a nutty flavor to the dishes.
3- Butter: Increases the thickness and emulsification of products.
4- Powdered sugar: Acts as a sweetener and raises the consistency of the frosting.
5- Vanilla extract: Enhances the taste of the food and gives depth to the food as well.
Step-by-Step Recipe
1- Prepare the Ingredients: Ensure that the cream cheese and the butter are placed at room temperature so that they can mix well with others.
2- Beat the Cream Cheese and Butter: When that happens use an electric mixer to beat until light and fluffy.
3- Add Peanut Butter: Add the peanut butter and go on mixing them until they are well mixed.
4- Gradually Add Powdered Sugar: Pulse it in gradually until you get the right taste and consistency that you want your cake to have.
5- Add Vanilla Extract: Stir well until the ingredients are well incorporated.
The first time I made this frosting you would think that it would take forever to prepare but boy was I wrong. In less than 30 minutes I had a dish full of the tastiest and richest frosting that I had ever had the pleasure to taste. It was silky, not too sweet, and peanut as I wanted it to be.
Variations to Try
1- Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting: For a change add 1/4 cup of cocoa powder into the frosting to give it a chocolate feel.
2- Honey Peanut Butter Frosting: Use less powdered sugar and instead add honey in the same quantity because it is a natural sweetener.
3- Crunchy Peanut Butter Frosting: For more texture, instead of buying the smooth peanut butter, buy the crunchy one.
Citations from Famous Chefs
Ina Garten: βWhat is more, the frosting, made of peanut butter and cream cheese, turns out to be rather rich, slightly sour, yet beyond delicious. β
Ree Drummond: βThis frosting is good for people who do not want to have a sweet on top of the bread like cake or anything else. I felt that it had really good flavor in it. β
Pro Tips for Perfect Frosting
1- Consistency: If the frosting turns thick, add a tablespoon of milk to it. If itβs too thin, then add more of the powdered sugar into the mix to thicken it again.
2- Chilling: Also, it should be noted, that when using the frosting it will become easier to spread if chilled for 15 minutes.
3- Storing: Store it in an airtight jar in the fridge for about a week. Re-whip before using.
There are a few issues that I have experimented with different techniques for years to archive the following frosting. Well, waiting for some time before spreading has been magical to me. It makes spreading frosting easier and gives cakes a polished, professional look.
Decorating Ideas
1- Cupcakes: Frost cupcakes and pipe the frosting on top and cherry chopped peanuts on the frosting.
2- Layer Cakes: Drizzled for a taste of flavoring between layers in a chocolate banana cake.
3- Cookies: Drizzled on sugar cookies or can be used to make delicious sandwich cookies by placing them in between two chocolate chip cookies.
On the occasion of my sonβs birthday, I decided I was going to shoot the moon. For this part, I decided to bake a layered chocolate cake and applied the Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting in between the layers of the chocolate cake. To this, I piped more harmless swirls on top and garnished with chopped peanuts. My friends loved the cake and all of them demanded the recipe for this cake.
Nutritional highlights
Here are the details regarding the nutritional value per serving of kelp:
β’ Calories: 220
β’ Fat: 15g
β’ Sugar: 16g
β’ Protein: 4g
Of course, this frosting is a special indulgence but itβs good to know what is going into it. The only time I donβt bother much about the calories is when preparing it to be served on occasions such as parties, weddings, etc., but it does help to be informed.
FAQs
1- Is It Possible To Prepare This Frosting In Advance? Indeed it can be prepared in advance and kept in the refrigerator for up to one week. Just re-whip before using.
2- Is it Possible To Utilize Natural Peanut Butter? Yes, but the consistency of the product may not be the same. More powdered sugar may be added to achieve the desired consistency or a little milk drizzled on in the process. 3- How Long is this frosting good for again? It only lasts up to one week if it is stored inside the refrigerator.
After the party, my son and I had some frosting left which I put in a fridge to save it. A few days later I quickly recreated it and used it to frost some cupcakes. The frosting was still tasty and moist just as I had remembered it and this went a long way toward confirming the fact that this is one of the best frostings one can prepare in advance.
Conclusion
This recipe is delicious and can be applied to any dessert it just makes your dish all the more wonderful! By following these instructions which contain a list of additional helpful tips, as well as the wide-ranging delicious varieties of frosting flavors provided you will be equipped to make any frosting needed for any occasion. Iβm low on posting: Iβll note this as itβs an easy and sure-fire frosting for bakers of all expertise levels.
Reading through all the times Iβve made this frosting, I could not help but be overwhelmed by the simple pleasures that have added value to our family transactions. The meaning of a recipe does not only stop at a manual that contains instructions for preparing food but it is a culture that people now follow. I suggest that you try it and make this dish the favorite food of your family.
